Request a Demo Search

15 Odd Things That Make Direct Mail Fundraising Appeals Successful

Donor-Centered Approach
Topics -

Easily Manage Your Donor & Fundraising Needs in Bloomerang!

Schedule a Demo

The doctor I interviewed for a recent appeal was great. We got into this geeky discussion of recent neuroscience and how it can shape behavior. He uses it with patients, to keep them on their meds. I use it with prospects, to gently guide them to give.

Still, he’s no direct mail expert. And he’ll be getting a letter to review, a letter I wrote, to be sent out over his signature. Is there room for misunderstanding? Oh, yeah. The person signing your appeal might wonder… “Why does good direct mail sound so weird?”

Direct mail appeals are unlike any other writing on earth. So, to prepare him, I listed some of their “strange but true” aspects in the brief below.

Maybe you’ll find it helpful the next time a signatory looks at your draft appeal and exclaims, “Yikes! That doesn’t sound like me!”

Here are some of the odd things that make direct mail fundraising appeals function well

1. Direct mail fundraising appeals are not brochures, with lots of details about the charity and its programs. Insiders care about that stuff. Outsiders don’t.

2. Good direct mail appeals have a few standard components. They always have “entertainment value” (often a story, or intimacy: “Let me take you into my world.”); that’s what keeps people reading. They have multiple requests for a gift (inertia is a BIG problem, so you beat readers over the head with “asks”). They have a conversational voice: the letter signer talks directly to the letter recipient. The pronouns “I” and “you” are copiously present.

3. Neuroscientists have observed in the lab that making a gift to charity lights up a pleasure center in the human brain. A good direct mail letter, therefore, “models” that act for the reader, by suggesting it repeatedly. The reader begins to envision the gift, and in envisioning starts to feel the pleasure.

4. “You” is the most important word. It is classed among the top 20 or so “power words” in advertising because of its magical ability to raise more money.

5. Effective direct mail appeals aren’t really about how wonderful the charity is. They are, instead, about how wonderful donors are. Making donors feel important is Job #1. It’s called “donor-centricity.” It’s exactly like “customer-centricity.”

6. Neuroscience has discovered a very useful thing about our brains: “Even when people perceive that flattery is insincere, that flattery can still leave a lasting and positive impression of the flatterer.” In other words, you cannot overdo donor love.

7. You wear your heart on your sleeve. Sounding corporate or technical will not raise as much money as sounding warm and welcoming.

8. Researchers in donor direct fundraising, like Dr. Adrian Sargeant, who did his tests with National Public Radio, have found that so-called “social information” – such as how much others have given – leads to bigger and more gifts from average donors.

9. Direct mail deeply respects reader convenience. Good direct mail is highly “skimmable”: short words, short sentences, short paragraphs.

10. Professional direct mail — littered as it is with sentence fragments, ellipses (…) and grammatical no-no’s such as sentences that start with a conjunction — would earn an “F” in 10th-grade English class. But the products of 10th-grade English class would fail miserably in the mailbox.

11. People tend to skim the underlines first, eye-motion studies show. So we underline key messages. You should be able to read JUST the underlines and kind of get what’s being asked of you. Corollary: you don’t have to underline the entire phrase you wish to emphasize. Since the eye sees “word clumps,” the NON-underlined words to the right and left of the underlined words will also be read.

12. For the same reason, direct mail letters use devices like bullet lists and ultra-short paragraphs … because they make it easier to skim.

13. There are two types of letters: those sent to people who have given previously, and those sent to people who have not. Those who have given before are likely to give again, often without even reading the letter. But it is very difficult to acquire new donors. From a mailing of 200 professionally-written appeals, maybe 10% will open the envelope. And from that 10%, only one gift will come in … for a one-half of one percent return. (And yet the math works, if you retain that new donor for a while. The real money comes in subsequent years. The biggest gift a donor ever makes is usually around the 6th-8th gift, says one Canadian expert.)

14. Certain phrases, like “tax-deductible” (which reminds readers that you’re a true charity), are repeated often, so they won’t be missed.

15. We write (and review) these letters at 1 mph. Readers, though, read at 100 mph. Things that are said just once tend to be overlooked. When you read direct mail at 1 mph (listen up, reviewers!), it can sound choppy. That choppiness disappears at 100 mph.

As you can see, direct mail fundraising has the potential to be a powerful source of revenue despite being an often overlooked route. A successful direct mail campaign, like any other channel, will involve a good amount of planning and strategy. For more information, feel free to check out the informational resources below:

  • 5 Enticing Ways to Catch your Donors’ Attention: Breaking through the clutter and grabbing supporters’ attention is more difficult than ever before. However, in a world dominated by digital strategies, direct mail is often the way to do so! Check out this guide to grabbing (and keeping!) your donors’ attention in a busy world.
  • Copywriting Tips for Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising: It’s possible to write powerful and effective direct mail fundraising appeals even if you don’t have an English degree. By following these tried-and-true copywriting tips, you’ll be well on your way to a successful campaign.
  • How to Personalize Your Nonprofit Fundraising: Did you know that recipients are more likely to read through your fundraising appeal if it’s addressed to them by name? In order to be the organization that stands out to your supporters, be sure to implement these key personalization strategies.

This post originally appeared in the Ahern Donor Communications newsletter.

How to Write a Fundraising Plan in 2 Steps!

Download the eBook

Exclusive Resources

Related Articles


  • Redstart Roundup | July 22, 2020 - Redstart Creative

    […] 15 Odd Things That Make Direct Mail Fundraising Appeals Successful […]
  • Sandra Tanzer

    Hello Bloomerang and Tom Ahern: Re: direct mail or direct email fund raising letters - I'd like to know some good closing lines - after the solicitor has made the ask and told the prospect how to respond / remit. Can you recommend something other than "We hope we hear from you soon!" Thank you very much!
  • Direct Mail Fundraising | WorkPlacePro Blog

    […] As Bloomerang explains it, donating to a nonprofit lights up the brain’s pleasure center. Each time they read a […]
Leave a reply