The face-off: eTapestry vs. Bloomerang. Bloomerang’s cloud-based donor management software has all the benefits you’ve come to expect from eTapestry: unlimited users, an integrated email tool, mobile access and real-time support. However, our paths diverge when you consider ease-of-use, pricing and training — making Bloomerang an even better alternative to eTapestry.

Compare for yourself:

eTapestry vs. Bloomerang

eTapestry

  • 0-1,000 records
  • $175a month
  • Outdated, complicated user-interface
  • Additional fees for advanced functionality
  • Difficult to use on mobile
  • Additional fees for email analytics
  • 10 online giving forms/pages
  • 10,000 emails per year
  • $49 a month for training
  • Errors when used by concurrent users
  • Query-based reporting
  • Minimal product roadmap
  • Lack of true integrations
  • Errors when used by concurrent users
  • Payment-enabled fee of $50/month from Blackbaud
  • Nickel and dime charges without warning
  • Outdated interface and no updates for years
  • Standard reporting is not customizable
  • Knowledgebase and training videos not included in subscription
  • Unresolved support tickets + poor and slow follow up with phone support tickets | Support has been deprioritized by Blackbaud
  • Social media tool doesn’t record activity – only notes when someone is on a social platform
  • Software Advice reviews
  • TrustRadius reviews
  • G2 Crowd reviews

Bloomerang

  • 0-1,000 records
  • $99a month
  • Modern, friendly user-interface
  • All features come standard
  • Dedicated mobile app
  • Built-in email analytics come standard
  • Unlimited online giving forms/pages
  • 60,000 emails per year
  • Free group training
  • No errors when used by concurrent users
  • Filter-based reporting
  • Weekly improvements via a continuous release cycle
  • Great integrations with Donorsearch, TrueGivers, QuickBooks Online, MailChimp, Qgiv, Givebutter, Zapier, and many others
  • Unlimited concurrent users
  • No extra payment fees
  • All pricing upfront and included in original proposal
  • Product is updated weekly
  • All standard reports can be customized and saved
  • New trainings included with subscription & released every month
  • Daily audits to ensure all support tickets are resolved + phone support voicemails answered same day
  • Twitter integration pulls in tweets through the Social Listening tool
  • Software Advice reviews
  • TrustRadius reviews
  • G2 Crowd reviews

eTaptestry Pricing and Fees

How much does eTapestry cost? Here’s the breakdown — you do the math.

Their ‘Starter’ package is $175 per month for up to 1,000 records with unlimited users and only 3 DIY online forms included.

The equivalent Bloomerang package for 0 – 1,000 records is $76 a month cheaper than eTaptestry and includes unlimited online giving pages/forms. No need to cap it at three!

Click here to learn more about Bloomerang’s pricing and packages.

 

Get A Live Demo

Want to take a closer look at our software?

Get A Custom Demo And Ask How You Can Receive Your FREE Standard eTaptestry Conversion!
Get A Live Demo

 

eTapestry vs. Bloomerang: See the difference for yourself

alternative to eTapestry

eTapestry Dashboard

Bloomerang dashboard

Bloomerang Dashboard

Common eTapestry Customer Complaints: Hear from nonprofit leaders who made the switch

Bloomerang has a unique, modern interface that is clean, fresh, and very intuitive – allowing fundraisers to complete tasks more efficiently and effectively!

We take pride in the claim that no training is required to use Bloomerang, making it a great alternative to eTapestry.

Our customers use Bloomerang to manage their entire constituent ecosystem, including donors, volunteers, sponsors, grantees and more. Real-time retention and engagement metrics come standard, and our knowledgeable, local support team is here to help you every step of the way.

See more customer success stories here >>

One of the big things about moving from Etap to Bloomerang was the ease of running reports and having them saved and update on their own. While it was possible to save reports in Etap, they were so difficult to run that when someone asked for a specific report, it would take up to 2 hours just to run it. It wasn’t user friendly – rather, it was expert friendly. We have come to appreciate how easy it is to not only edit a profile in Bloomerang but to use the reports, add items easily to someones profile, and keep track. I use the website daily, whereas at Etap, I was on it a couple times a week. I think it says something about Bloomerang as the database is SO EASY to use, plus the customer support team is incredible and very friendly. I haven’t really run into any issues with support in terms of helping me find something or understand something that doesn’t make sense. Being able to talk to someone or chat with them instantly has been extremely valuable especially in the summer when camp is in session and we are less on time.
Kevin Friduss

 

First, eTap was designed so someone in IT could operate, Bloomerang is set up so a fundraiser can operate the system. Next, to be honest, I was never a fan of eTap – it is an antiquated system that required much too much work arounds with each work around costing literally thousands. The customer service was spotty at best, and it is my understanding Blackbaud was phasing out eTap (not sure if this is true) trying to get their customers to move up into an original Blackbuad product. Overall, eTap is way past its usefulness as a database and too difficult to pull information out and enter information in.
Roger Sheffield

 

As a long time etapestry user, we were incredibly frustrated by the reporting functionality of this CRM. Candidly, getting reports out of etapestry was like trying to nail jello to a tree. Additionally, the customer service availability was frustrating and expensive, and I felt like we were constantly being “Nickled and dimed” by Blackbaud for the use of the software, processing donations through their platform, etc. I would tell them that I don’t know why we waited so long to make the switch. I was worried about the time needed for migration, data integrity, etc. The transition was SO easy and seamless. Looking back, I feel like we wasted a lot of money staying with etapestry/Blackbaud. I would highly recommend making the move to Bloomerang.
Theresa Brun

 

 

Learn more about our world-class customer support.

No matter what fundraising software you purchase, the best software is always going to be the one you are comfortable using. Because of this, Bloomerang is committed to ensuring that every customer has free access to chat and email with our knowledgeable and helpful Customer Support Team. A few years ago, one of our wonderful customers described our Customer Support Team as “both helpful and human,” and our team has taken that motto to heart. We guarantee that any time you work with our team, you will always be working with a real human employed by Bloomerang who will keep working for you until your questions are answered.

You don’t just have to take our word for it though. See what some of our current nonprofit customers have to say.

The best part, though, is the support team. They are quick to respond and provide setup advice that is tailored to the client. I’ve never had an unanswered question.”

“Even better, their support is second to none. Any question is addressed thoughtfully and quickly. And, every single person I have interacted with has been friendly.”

“Bloomerang’s support features are unmatched among peer service providers. I advise all of my clients to use the chat support feature; the support representatives are prompt and knowledgeable.”

 

Get A Live Demo

Want to take a closer look at our software?

Get A Custom Demo And Ask How You Can Receive Your FREE Standard eTaptestry Conversion!
Get A Live Demo